Players: I
- Chris Iannetta Batter · 2015–2019
- Andy Ibáñez Batter · 2021–2026
- Jose Iglesias Batter · 2015–2025
- Raisel Iglesias Pitcher · 2015–2026
- Tatsuya Imai Pitcher · 2026
- Shota Imanaga Pitcher · 2024–2026
- Ender Inciarte Batter · 2015–2022
- Jonathan India Batter · 2021–2026
- Greg Infante Pitcher · 2017–2018
- Omar Infante Batter · 2015–2016
- Cole Irvin Pitcher · 2019–2026
- Jake Irvin Pitcher · 2023–2026
- Kyle Isbel Batter · 2021–2026
- Hisashi Iwakuma Pitcher · 2015–2017